How Do CO2 Flame Machines Compare to Gas Flame Machines?
, by Katy Chen, 12 min reading time
How Do CO2 Flame Machines Compare to Gas Flame Machines?
The biggest difference? Gas flame machines create real, hot flames through combustion, while CO2 "flame machines" create a safe, cold plume of fog that's lit by LEDs to look like a flame. They're fundamentally different types of special effects equipment designed for different applications. Understanding these differences is crucial for choosing the right effect for your event, ensuring both safety and the visual impact you're after.
What is a Gas Flame Machine?
A gas flame machine (also called a flame projector) creates actual fire using combustible fuel—typically propane or other flammable gases. These machines work by carefully controlling the release and ignition of the gas to produce real flames that can reach impressive heights. The result is an authentic fire effect that adds dramatic impact to outdoor concerts, large-scale events, and theatrical productions.
Key Characteristics of Gas Flame Machines
- Produces real, hot flames through actual combustion
- Creates authentic fire with natural movement and color
- Requires strict safety perimeters and often special permits
- Best suited for outdoor venues or large, well-ventilated indoor spaces
- Typically uses propane, LPG, or other flammable gases as fuel
- Creates dramatic visual impact with flame heights of several meters
- Requires professional operation and safety monitoring
Advantages
- Authentic fire appearance with natural movement
- Impressive visual impact and "wow factor"
- Greater flame height potential (up to 8-10 meters)
- Real heat effect that audiences can feel
- No need for additional lighting or fog effects
Disadvantages
- Significant fire hazard requiring strict safety protocols
- Requires special permits and often fire marshal approval
- Limited indoor use due to ventilation requirements
- Higher insurance costs and liability concerns
- Requires greater safety distances from performers and audience
What is a "CO2 Flame Machine"?
Despite the name, a CO2 "flame machine" doesn't actually produce fire. Instead, it creates a powerful jet of cold CO2 fog that's illuminated by colored LED lights to create the appearance of flames. This creates a visually striking effect that mimics fire without the associated risks of actual combustion.
Key Characteristics of CO2 Flame Machines
- Produces cold, harmless plumes of CO2 fog illuminated by LEDs
- No actual fire or combustion involved in the effect
- Safer for indoor use and closer proximity to performers
- Creates fast, powerful burst effects with customizable colors
- Uses liquid CO2 tanks as the effect source
- Requires less restrictive safety measures than real flame effects
- Offers RGB color customization not possible with real flames
Advantages
- Safe for indoor venues and closer proximity to performers
- Customizable colors through RGB LED technology
- No fire hazard or real combustion
- Fewer permit requirements and regulatory hurdles
- Lower insurance and liability concerns
- Quick dissipation with no lingering effects
Disadvantages
- Less realistic than actual flames
- Requires proper ventilation to prevent CO2 buildup
- Limited effect duration compared to gas flames
- Liquid CO2 tanks can be heavy and require special handling
- Higher ongoing operational costs for CO2 refills
Head-to-Head Comparison: The Key Differences
When deciding between CO2 and gas flame machines for your event, several critical factors come into play. Let's break down the most important differences to help you make an informed choice.
Safety & Venue Restrictions
Safety considerations often become the deciding factor when choosing between these technologies. Gas flame machines create actual fire, bringing inherent risks that require strict safety protocols, fire-resistant surroundings, and often special permits. Many venues simply won't allow real flames indoors.
CO2 "flame" machines, by contrast, produce no actual fire or extreme heat, making them significantly safer for indoor use. However, they do require proper ventilation to prevent CO2 buildup in enclosed spaces, which could potentially cause breathing issues in poorly ventilated areas.
| Safety Consideration | Gas Flame Machine | CO2 "Flame" Machine |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum Safe Distance | 10-15 feet (3-5 meters) | 3-5 feet (1-1.5 meters) |
| Indoor Use | Limited to specially designed venues | Suitable for most venues with ventilation |
| Permits Required | Fire marshal approval, special licenses | Minimal or none in most jurisdictions |
| Proximity to Materials | No flammable materials within 15+ feet | Standard stage materials acceptable |
| Emergency Shutdown | Multiple safety systems required | Simple shutdown procedures |
Visual Effect & Realism
The visual impact of these two technologies differs significantly. Gas flame machines produce authentic fire with natural movement, color, and heat. The organic nature of real flames creates an unmistakable effect that's difficult to replicate.
CO2 "flame" machines create a more stylized effect. While not actually fire, the LED-illuminated CO2 plumes can produce vibrant colors not possible with natural flames, including blues, greens, and purples. The effect is more controlled and uniform but lacks the organic movement of real fire.
Use Cases: When to Choose Which?
Your specific event requirements will largely determine which technology makes more sense. Here's a quick guide to help you decide:
Choose Gas Machines When:
- You need authentic fire effects for outdoor concerts
- Your venue is a large-scale stadium or festival ground
- You have proper safety personnel and protocols in place
- You've secured necessary permits and insurance
- You want the dramatic impact of real flames
- Your budget allows for additional safety measures
Choose CO2 "Flame" Machines When:
- You're performing in nightclubs or indoor venues
- You need effects in closer proximity to performers
- You want customizable colors beyond natural flame hues
- You need quick, dramatic burst effects
- You face venue restrictions on open flames
- Safety is a primary concern for your production
A Note on Transport and Care
Both types of flame effect machines represent significant investments for your production company. Proper transport and storage are essential to protect these valuable assets and ensure their reliable performance show after show.
Gas flame machines contain sensitive ignition systems and fuel management components that can be damaged during transport. CO2 machines feature delicate LED lighting systems and precision nozzles that require protection. Both types benefit from custom-fitted cases that prevent movement during transit and shield components from impact.
How should I transport my flame machine between events?
Always transport your flame machine in a custom-fitted case that prevents movement and protects sensitive components. For gas flame machines, ensure all fuel lines are properly disconnected and capped. For CO2 machines, protect LED systems and nozzles from impact. Use cases with proper foam inserts that cradle your equipment securely.
What maintenance is required between shows?
For gas flame machines, regularly inspect fuel lines, connections, and ignition systems for wear or damage. Clean nozzles to prevent blockage. For CO2 machines, check LED systems, clean nozzles, and inspect CO2 connections. Both types benefit from test firing in a controlled environment before each event to ensure reliable performance.
Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Event
The choice between CO2 and gas flame machines isn't about which is "better" overall—it's about which is right for your specific event, venue, and safety requirements. Gas flame machines deliver authentic fire effects with unmatched realism but come with significant safety considerations. CO2 "flame" machines offer versatility, customizable colors, and safer operation, especially in indoor environments.
Whichever you choose, remember that these special effects create memorable moments for your audience. And once you've made your investment in flame effect technology, protecting that equipment becomes just as important as the show itself.
Ready to Add Flame Effects to Your Event?
Contact our expert team today for a no-obligation quote. We can help you choose the right flame machine—whether CO2 or gas—for your specific venue, budget, and safety requirements.
Contact Our Team for a Quote
